Vanilla ice cream with olive oil and sea salt: a surprisingly good dessert
Yes, it works, and it tastes better than it sounds. A teaspoon of fruity olive oil and a small pinch of fleur de sel round out vanilla ice cream: the sweetness tastes less flat, and a gentle peppery note lingers on the finish. Only three things matter: good ice cream, an extra virgin olive oil with real character and not too much salt.
It takes five minutes’ work, plus ten minutes to chill the bowls, and you don’t need an ice cream maker. For guests, serve small amaretti biscuits or toasted bread on the side. For a fruitier version, use a mandarin oil. Below: how much oil to use per serving, and why the combination works.
Time: 15 mins · Serves: 4 · Difficulty: easy
By Babak Kharabi. Header image: created with AI.
Ingredients
- 500 ml good vanilla ice cream (about 8 scoops)
- 1½ tbsp BUTTINALE73 Manufaktur (a generous 1 tsp per serving)
- 4 small pinches of fleur de sel
- 12 small amaretti biscuits or 2 slices day-old ciabatta
- 1 tbsp BUTTINALE73 Manufaktur, for toasting (bread only)
- 1 tsp sugar (optional, for the bread)
- For the variation: 1 tbsp BUTTINALE73 Manufaktur Mandarin instead of the 1½ tbsp Manufaktur (about ¾ tsp per serving)
- For the variation (optional): grated zest of ½ unwaxed mandarin
Method
- Chill the bowls. Put four small bowls in the freezer for 10 minutes, so the ice cream doesn’t melt the moment the oil goes on. Make sure the oil is at room temperature.
- Toast the bread (optional). Cut the ciabatta into finger-thick strips. Heat 1 tbsp Manufaktur in a frying pan over a medium heat and fry the bread for 3 to 4 minutes until golden and crisp. If you like, sprinkle over 1 tsp sugar at the end and let it caramelise briefly. Leave to cool on a wire rack. If you’re using amaretti, skip this step.
- Let the ice cream soften. Take the ice cream out of the freezer 5 minutes before serving. Slightly softened ice cream is easier to scoop, and the oil clings to it better.
- Scoop. Put two scoops in each chilled bowl. Press a small hollow into the top scoop with the back of a spoon for the oil to pool in.
- Oil and salt. Drizzle a generous 1 tsp Manufaktur over each serving in a thin stream. Crush a small pinch of fleur de sel between your fingers and sprinkle it over. For the variation, use about ¾ tsp Manufaktur Mandarin per serving instead and grate over a little mandarin zest.
- Serve. Add the amaretti or toasted bread on the side and serve straight away. Take the first spoonful with oil, salt and ice cream all together, not one after the other.
Why olive oil works on ice cream
Many flavour compounds dissolve better in fat than in water. The oil forms a thin film on the cold ice cream and keeps the vanilla on your tongue for longer. It also adds notes of its own: green, fruity, sometimes almondy. They work because vanilla is itself round and mellow.
The second thing is contrast. A good extra virgin olive oil is slightly bitter, with a peppery finish that cuts through the sugar and cream. The fleur de sel does the rest: it crunches between your teeth, and the sweetness tastes clearer afterwards. If you wonder where that tickle in your throat comes from, we explain why in Why good olive oil catches in your throat.
Which oil, which ice cream, which salt
- Oil: extra virgin olive oil only. It’s eaten raw, so any fault comes through. More on the terms on the label in Extra virgin, virgin, cold pressed.
- Ice cream: vanilla ice cream made with milk, cream, egg yolk and real vanilla. The denser it is, the better it holds the oil. Fior di latte works just as well.
- Salt: flaky salt such as fleur de sel. Fine salt dissolves straight away and just tastes salty.
Common mistakes
- Too much oil: more than ½ tbsp per serving pools in the bottom of the bowl and tastes greasy.
- Cold oil: olive oil from the fridge turns cloudy and starts to set. That’s not a fault, but it doesn’t spread well. Use it at room temperature.
- Old oil: olive oil doesn’t improve with age. If it smells musty or of stale fat, keep it away from your dessert.
Which oil we use
For the classic version we use our BUTTINALE73 Manufaktur: grassy and fruity, with notes of almond and artichoke and a gentle peppery finish. That peppery finish is exactly what makes the difference here. The olives are harvested and pressed on the same day at our own olive mill in Paciano, Umbria, below 27 °C.
For the variation we use BUTTINALE73 Manufaktur Mandarin, a flavoured olive oil. Its citrus notes go well with vanilla and amaretti. The flavour is stronger, so you need a little less. If you have both bottles, drizzle half a teaspoon of each over every serving.
Common questions
Doesn’t olive oil on ice cream taste like salad?
No, as long as you get the amount right. It’s usually the vinegar that makes something taste like salad, not the oil. On cold, sweet ice cream, a fruity oil comes across more like green apple, almond or freshly cut grass. Start with a teaspoon and work your way up.
Which ice cream flavours work apart from vanilla?
Flavours with plenty of milk and little fruit work well: fior di latte, pistachio, chocolate or hazelnut. Very sharp fruit sorbets are trickier, because the acidity and the oil sit side by side instead of blending. On lemon sorbet, a drop works better than a teaspoon.
Can I use other flavoured oils on ice cream?
Yes, but not all of them. Citrus oils such as lemon or mandarin are a natural match for vanilla, and rosemary goes with honey or nut ice cream. Garlic and truffle don’t belong on a dessert.
Can I make this dessert ahead?
Only partly. You can toast the bread an hour ahead; it stays crisp if left uncovered on a wire rack. Don’t add the oil and salt until just before serving, or the salt dissolves and the oil runs into the bowl.
How much olive oil do you put on vanilla ice cream?
A generous teaspoon per serving is enough. More than ½ tablespoon pools in the bottom of the bowl and tastes greasy. The oil should be at room temperature so it spreads.
Which salt goes with ice cream and olive oil?
Flaky salt such as fleur de sel works best. It crunches between your teeth and makes the sweetness taste clearer. Fine salt dissolves straight away and just tastes salty.
What olive oil goes with vanilla ice cream?
Use an extra virgin olive oil that’s fruity with a slightly peppery finish. It’s eaten raw, so any fault comes through. The peppery finish cuts through the sugar and cream and rounds out the ice cream.
You might also like
All recipes
Courgette carpaccio with lemon oil: raw, wafer-thin and quick to make
Shave young courgettes raw into wafer-thin ribbons, season them just before serving and dress with 2 tbsp extra virgin olive oil and 1 tbsp lemon oil. Finish with Parmesan shavings, toasted pine...

Pesto alla genovese: why the olive oil makes or breaks it
Classic pesto alla genovese with basil, pine nuts, garlic, Parmesan and Pecorino: quantities in tablespoons, pestle and mortar or a chilled blender, pasta water to bring it together, and which olive oil...

Verdure grigliate: chargrilled vegetables marinated in olive oil
Griddle courgettes, aubergine and peppers without oil, then marinate them while still warm in olive oil with garlic, herbs and vinegar. With exact oil quantities, how long they keep in the fridge...














